Boat Insurance: What Buyers Need Before Closing
<p>If you are financing the boat, the lender will not release the money until it sees proof of insurance with its name on the policy, and many marinas want proof of liability coverage before they will sign a slip contract. So the policy is a closing item. Here is what a boat policy covers, what Progressive says its customers paid on average, and the paperwork to have lined up before you hand over the check.</p>
November 19, 2026
Who requires boat insurance
Most states do not make you carry it. Maryland's insurance regulator says outright that no law, regulation or rule there requires insurance on a boat or personal watercraft, and that is the norm across the country. Utah is a clear exception. Its Financial Responsibility of Motorboat Owners and Operators Act requires owner's or operator's liability security on motorboats used on state waters, and the state's boating site lists the minimums as $25,000/$50,000 bodily injury, $15,000 property damage, or $65,000 combined per accident. Boats with a manufacturer-listed rating of 50 horsepower or less are exempt, but personal watercraft are covered regardless of horsepower. Utah also says proof of insurance has to be on board whenever the boat is running.
The bigger practical requirement comes from your lender. The BoatUS Boat Buyers Guide is blunt about it: you will not get a boat loan without showing the bank proof of insurance covering the full value of the boat, and the bank is listed on the policy as lienholder so it appears as co-payee on any loss check. If you are still shopping for financing, our boat loan terms guide covers the rates and down payments lenders were advertising this month.
Marinas are the third gatekeeper. The same BoatUS guide says most marinas want proof of liability insurance before they accept a slip or mooring contract, and some want to be named as an additional insured. BoatUS sells a dock contract liability endorsement for exactly this situation, so read the marina contract before you buy the policy, not after.
What happens if you skip it on a financed boat
Washington's insurance commissioner warns that if you do not carry coverage, the bank may buy force-placed insurance, which costs more than a policy you buy yourself. Maryland's consumer guide walks through what that means with numbers: you buy a $25,000 boat, borrow $15,000, and let your policy lapse. The lender places coverage up to its $15,000 interest and adds the premium to your monthly payment. If the boat is then a total loss, the lender gets its loan balance and you get nothing, even though you had $10,000 of equity in the boat.
Homeowners coverage usually falls short
A lot of buyers assume the house policy picks up the boat. For a canoe or a small jon boat it might, partly. The NAIC says the personal property coverage on a homeowners policy may cover a small boat for $1,500 or less in physical damage, with limited liability protection, and that large boats are excluded for both property and liability. The Texas Department of Insurance adds that homeowners policies cover boat damage only to a limited dollar amount and do not provide liability coverage for it. Washington notes that the liability piece, when there is one, is generally tied to the boat's size and the motor's horsepower.
BoatUS adds that if your state, bank or marina requires insurance, a homeowners policy generally will not satisfy them.
Agreed value vs actual cash value
This is the choice that matters most when a boat is destroyed. Regulators describe three ways a policy can settle a loss:
- Actual cash value (ACV): you get the boat's current market value, minus your deductible. Texas gives the example of a boat that cost $40,000 new in 2010 and is worth $25,000 today; an ACV policy pays up to $25,000. The NAIC adds that on a partial loss, ACV pays the depreciated value of what was damaged.
- Agreed value: you and the insurer settle on a number when the policy starts, and that is what you get for a total loss, minus the deductible. Per the NAIC, partial losses are paid on a replacement cost basis with no depreciation taken.
- Replacement cost: the insurer pays to replace your boat with one as similar as possible.
BoatUS, whose policies are underwritten by GEICO Marine, offers the first two plus a liability-only policy. Its agreed hull value policy is available for most boat types except PWCs, and its ACV policy is pitched at runabouts, ski boats, PWCs and boats without a lienholder. Liability only is its cheapest option, but it is available only on boats owned outright with no lienholder. If you are borrowing, plan on hull coverage.
What Progressive says boaters paid
The regulators I checked publish no average premiums, so the cleanest numbers come from a single carrier. Progressive's page, updated November 14, 2024, says the average annual cost of its boat policies in 2024 to 2025 ranged from $274.42 in Wisconsin to $867.86 in Florida. It groups states into three tiers:
- Low-cost states, $307.01 average: includes Michigan, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania and Missouri.
- Medium-cost states, $413.34 average: includes Georgia, North Carolina, Tennessee, Ohio and Washington.
- High-cost states, $662.51 average: includes Florida, Texas, California, New York, Louisiana and South Carolina.
Progressive's explanation tracks with what you see at the ramp: bigger, pricier boats on the coasts, smaller boats on inland water around the Great Lakes, and a shorter season up north. If you are browsing boats for sale in Florida, Texas or California, all three sit in its high-cost group. These are one carrier's averages, so quote the specific boat before you budget.
Progressive lists boat type, horsepower, the boat's age, your boating history and a safety course as rating factors. Maryland's guide adds claims history and deductible, and says a higher deductible means a lower premium. BoatUS advertises up to 10% off for a boating safety course, multiple boat policies or a GEICO auto policy.
Read the exclusions before you sign
Maryland lists typical exclusions that catch owners out: wear and tear, corrosion, rot, mechanical or electrical breakdown, freezing unless the boat was properly winterized, racing, and neglect. The BoatUS guide shows why the wear-and-tear clause matters. Many dockside sinkings start with a small part below the waterline, like a stuffing box or bellows, failing from age. Most insurers will not pay for the part, and some policies also refuse the consequential damage, meaning the boat on the bottom. BoatUS's own agreed value policy covers immediate damage from fire, explosion, sinking or collision.
Check the navigation limits too. Maryland warns that taking a boat outside a policy's territorial restriction may void coverage, and Texas notes some policies limit ocean use. Texas also flags layup provisions, which suspend coverage during the months the boat is not in use, so know your dates if you launch early.
A closing-day checklist
- Get quotes as soon as your offer is accepted, with the HIN, engine details and where the boat will be kept.
- Expect the insurer to ask for a condition and valuation survey on many used boats. The BoatUS guide says banks and insurers use the survey value to set the loan and hull value, and that insurers will usually require the surveyor's safety-critical recommendations to be fixed, with proof such as yard bills. Our marine survey cost guide has current surveyor rates.
- List the lender as lienholder or loss payee, and the marina as additional insured if the slip contract calls for it.
- Match the navigation area to where you will actually run the boat.
- Have the binder or declarations page in hand before closing, and keep proof aboard if you boat in Utah.
Frequently asked questions
Is boat insurance required by law?
In most states, no. Utah is one that does require it: motorboats over 50 horsepower and all personal watercraft need liability coverage of at least $25,000/$50,000 bodily injury and $15,000 property damage, or $65,000 combined. Lenders and many marinas require insurance even where the state does not.
How much does boat insurance cost?
Progressive reports that its 2024 to 2025 average annual boat policy ranged from $274.42 in Wisconsin to $867.86 in Florida, with tier averages of $307.01, $413.34 and $662.51 for its low, medium and high-cost states. Your premium will depend on the boat, where it is kept, your record and the coverage you pick.
Can I get liability-only insurance on a financed boat?
Usually not. BoatUS offers its liability-only policy only for boats owned outright with no lienholder, and lenders generally want coverage for the full value of the boat.
Does a boat policy cover my fishing gear and phone?
Not automatically. North Carolina's insurance department says personal effects not used to run the boat are generally not covered under physical damage, though some insurers sell extra coverage for fishing gear and electronics. BoatUS sells a personal effects add-on.
Sources
- https://www.progressive.com/answers/average-boat-insurance-cost/
- https://content.naic.org/article/consumer-insight-summer-safety-are-you-insured-summer-fun
- https://insurance.maryland.gov/Consumer/Documents/publications/boatownersinsguide.pdf
- https://www.tdi.texas.gov/tips/boat-insurance.html
- https://www.ncdoi.gov/consumers/auto-and-vehicle-insurance/boat-insurance
- https://www.insurance.wa.gov/insurance-resources/boatmarine-insurance/boatmarine-insurance
- https://www.boatus.com/products-and-services/boat-insurance
- https://www.boatus.com/products-and-services/boat-insurance/agreed-hull-value
- https://www.boatus.com/products-and-services/boat-insurance/actual-cash-value
- https://www.boatus.com/products-and-services/boat-insurance/liability-only
- https://www.boatus.com/assets/pdf/boat-buyers-guide.pdf
- https://recreation.utah.gov/boating-overview-original/rules-and-regulations/boating-registration-and-insurance/
- https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title73/Chapter18C/C73-18c_1800010118000101.pdf